you can say "плохой" and you can say "плохим", you also can say "плох"
Концерт вчера вечером был плохой! - The yesterday's concert was bad (best choice)
Концерт вчера вечером был плохим! - The yesterday's concert has been being bad (not a good choice for words)
Концерт вчера вечером был плох! - The yesterday's concert was bad/wasn't good
IMHO