It's looking rather grim in the Political Forum at the moment. Among the top 20 threads, more are locked than open. This gives a negative impression of the forum. Of course, we know that it's the events in Ukraine leading to strong feelings with many, and some people have overstepped the mark in terms of tone and accusations. Others have deliberately trolled, or ranted (I'm guilty too!).

How can we keep the forum open, allow people to voice their opinions and have fruitful political discussions regarding events in Russia and the ex USSR?

Before I say anything else, I want to admit my own guilt: I have been using this forum too much, and plan to use it less. But I have learnt incredibly much from listening to what people have to say, asking questions and following the discussions.

My observations:
  • Why do people swear and lash out in vitriolic rants? It won't convince anyone and is a bad reflection on you.
  • I think there is a need for a definition of trolling, and consequences for deliberate trolling, i.e. warnings, suspensions and banning.
  • Some people deliberately provoke and insult the moderator: Don't!
  • Should / could somebody else moderate or assist with moderating the political forum? It's a tough and ungrateful job, and it burns people out. Perhaps there should be a team of 2-4 people focussing on different languages? Ideally people who are able to take a neutral view on discussions and have thick skin.
  • Could the rules for warnings, suspensions and banning be clarified?