Printable View
Is unstressed "e" pronounced like "и"?
Is stressed "o" pronounced like "aw" in "law"(short "o" in English) or "o" in "low"(long "o" in English)? I seem to pronounce "o" in the middle of a word as "aw" in "law", but at the end of a word I seem to pronounce it as "o" in "low". Is this correct?
Well, as non-professional linguist I can say only IMHO. IMHO stressed "o" is pronnounced like in "law" no matter if it is in the middle or in the end of a word. Unstressed "e" pronounced like "и" but IMHO when unstressed both "e" and "и" pronounced like English schwa vowel. Not much difference really.Quote:
Originally Posted by whipback
No, it's totally incorrect. The unstressed Russian "o" is neither like in "law" nor like in "low".Quote:
Originally Posted by whipback
The stressed Russian "o" is pronounced like English "aw" in "saw", "law".
The unstressed Russian "o" is roughly just like Russian "a", although it depends on its position with respect to the stressed vowel in the word. If the unstressed "o" is in the preceding (the very preceding) syllable, it's like "a". If it follows it, or if it precedes the preceding syllable, it's "schwa".
Schwa = the "o" in "concern"
Russian "a" = like the "a" in "ah!"
Olya, you said it all well, but I think you missed something: no one asked about unstressed o.
Yes, I did. :-D Sorry, guys. :mrgreen:Quote:
Originally Posted by paulb
Unstressed e is like i. весна is /v'isná/
There are five possible stressed vowels in Russian, notated /a e i o u/. In Standard Russian there are three possible unstressed vowels, /a i u/. Generally what is written a and o merge into /a/, and what is spelled е и merge into /i/.
There is a tendency to keep the pronunciation /e/ at morpheme boundaries, sort of like pronouncing a word as it is spelled. Он читает доклад о своем доме. /čitájit/ or /čitájet/, /dóm'i/ or /dóm'e/ .
When I listen to the news I sometimes think I am hearing the past tense plural as /l'e/ instead of /l'i/.
Would like to hear native speakers' comments.
What about сeводня? I when I hear that, I hear a long "o" as in "low" or "hello"
Well, all textbooks say that at the end of "low" and "hello" there is a diphthong "ou" which is no in Russian at all. But IMHO what you hear is always more important than any textbook. Not sure that book really can help to get rid of accent. Just be sure that you hear native speaker.
Quote:
Originally Posted by whipback
Correct.Quote:
Originally Posted by whipback
Firstly, the vowel in “law” is NOT short. At least, if you speak more or less “classic” English. Secondly, the “o” in “low” is not ONE vowel, it’s a diphthong, and standard English does not have long diphthongs. All right. In Russian, we do NOT have long vowels, and we do NOT have diphthongs. The stressed “o” is pronounced, if loosely comparing to English, like “o” stressed in its normal variant.Quote:
Is stressed "o" pronounced like "aw" in "law"(short "o" in English) or "o" in "low"(long "o" in English)?
Since you are not aware of phonetic processes, this observation can be accepted.Quote:
I seem to pronounce "o" in the middle of a word as "aw" in "law", but at the end of a word I seem to pronounce it as "o" in "low". Is this correct?
Since you are not aware of phonetic processes, this observation can be accepted.[/quote:3rxfe12p]Quote:
Originally Posted by Rtyom
:off:
Why do people on this forum feel they need to give a lesson on something that doesn't have to do with the point of the post? I thank you for your help, but I don't need the English lesson.
1. The point of my first post was to learn correct pronunciation.
2. The vowel in law may not be short, but I never said it was. I said it was pronounced like a short o.
3. Just like #2, I was saying low was pronounced like a long o. I never said anything about long or short dipthongs or it being one vowel.
Please don't get off topic! It is annoying, frustrating, and doesn't help at all!
Why are newbies on this forum so rude?
Do they really think that people here must do something for them? Getting salary here, maybe?
You see, whipback, the problem is that the sound in "low" is not one vowel for Russians. Roughly, it sounds like "оу" (aw+ooh) to us. That's why Rtyom began to talk about dipthongs.
As for me, personally - I don't know how on earth you hear the "-ow" in "сегодня", but I would never say that the sound is anyhow similar to the "ow" in "low" as my Russian ear hears it. If you speak in Russian with all those "aw-ooh" instead of Russian o's, it'll turn out the typical strong English accent.
Russian /o/ is like the vowel in thought, caught. These are short vowels, but a little longer I think than the Russian correspondants.
Compare caught and кот
Are they pronounced the same except for length?
whipback whipped me back :crazy:
I’m sorry if it was annoying. But I don’t think what I pointed out could be called off-topic. Now you see how different people who speak different languages can hear the same sounds. I throwed in a small portion of theory to make things clearer and avoid confusion in the future.
Anyway, if this may suit you, I won’t answer at your requests. No problem. :dunno:
If we take two different pronunciations on this page http://www.wordreference.com/definition/caught, I'd say that in the American pronunciation there is too much touch of "a" (Russian "a")*. That's not at all like "кот" sounds. But the British pronunciation is very close, only the sound is a bit longer than in the Russian word.Quote:
Originally Posted by chaika
* The same here http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/caught. It sounds closer to Russian "кат" or something.
For me the main difference in pronunciation of caught and кот is not in vowel but in t - т. :) English "t" I hear usually like something intermediate between "т" and "ч".Quote:
Originally Posted by chaika
It just seemed to me that you were trying to give me a whole bunch of unneeded information. I thank you for your help, I was just frustrated that I got information that I didn't need and didn't really answer my question. I wasn't trying to be rude I just wanted to make sure you knew that your post didn't get to the point of my post, but now I understand why you stated that information...Quote:
Originally Posted by Rtyom
I never said anyone had to help me. If someone doesn't want to help me then they don't have to...Quote:
Originally Posted by Оля
And if the o in low sounds like oy then how about the o in hello or the German o, if you know German? Here are some other long o sounding words that might help: mow, doe, blow, grow, know, glow, etc. Those are the o's(oh) I hear in сегодня. I also hear them in the words школа, плохо, and хорошо
At 2:37 and 5:55 in this cartoon, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HkfNiQOJcuo , I hear two words that sound, to me, like they use long o's.
The penguin with the red beak speaks with German accent.Quote:
Originally Posted by whipback
By the way, it's very interesting thread. May be I will understand the difference between short and long o's if it continues. :roll:
Aa
long = ей(the name of the letter)
short = а
Ee
long = и(name of the letter)
short = э
Ii
long = ай(name of the letter)
short = ы(I believe the tongue placement on the Russian letter is different form the English i. I pronounce the English i with my tongue right behind my bottom teeth.)
Oo
long = from this forum it looks like there is not Russian equivalent. It sounds just like a German o(oh as in boat instead of aw as in bottle)(name of the letter)
short = о
Uu
long = ю(name of the letter)
short = а(unstressed)
and sometimes...
Yy
long = wай - as the word why(name of the letter and that was the best way I could translate it)
short = я(the a part of ya is pronounced like unstressed a)
Ww
long = double ю(name of the letter - the "double" is actually part of the word it is not meaning that w is pronounced as юю)
short = wa(unstressed a, no Russian equivalent to w)
This is the way Americans are taught the alphabet, but the letters are sometimes pronounced in a different ways than explained above ex. u sometimes is pronounced like Russian y, etc. Also this is translated from my understanding of the Cyrillic alphabet.
>long o sounding words that might help: mow, doe, blow, grow, know, glow, etc.
These are not long /o/. They are a sequence of a vowel plus a semiconsonant, which is the /w/ sound. I am not up to date on my phonetic terminology, maybe it's a semivowel, like /j/ which is usually spelled "y".
So you have phonemically (not the spelling!) /mow, dow, blow, grow, now, glow/. Our "long" vowel is really a diphthong, unlike the Russian stressed /o/, which is not. The word сегодня should sound like /s'ivódn'a/ where the /ó/ sounds like the BrE vowel in caught but is short because Russian does not have long vowels (generally). (apostrophe is the standard notation for palatalized consonant).
Оля, спасибо за ссылки на звуки. В некоторых наших диалектах caught звучит как кат, но в моей речи ясно звук "aw" а не [a]. Мой диалект - midwest (вырос под Чикаго).
....Never mind. Thank you for your help, you answered my question...Quote:
Originally Posted by chaika