Quote:
Originally Posted by VendingMachine
Quote:
Then I think here lies our main difference. I think that the law can't be built on nothing but public moral or we would have a lot of rights violating laws, such as law against adultery, for example (and we know instances when such laws existed and still exist in some societies).
It probably does, though I never said that laws could be built on
nothing but public moral,
I knew you didn't say that, I really expressed it badly, sorry. I should have said that the public moral, in my opinion, is not something that should be protected (from abusing) by the law.
Quote:
As for a law against adultry - the public moral has nothing against it, Friendy, wake up and smell the coffee.
:o Adultery was always condemned by public opinion, nowadays not as much as in previous times, but still.
Quote:
[quote:bqbm5mhl]why this law should or shouldn't exist and simply stating the fact of it's existence is irrelevant
It is relevant. If it's there it means it's there for a reason [/quote:bqbm5mhl]
So what? If there’s a reason for something to exist that doesn’t mean that it should exist. The robbers also have a reason for robbing - they want money. But this reason won't keep people from thinking that robbery shouldn't exist. And by that logic these swearing in public guys also have a reason for that, will it keep you from thinking that they shouldn't do it?
Quote:
…you don't see what that reason is, I can just about discern it, people with superior analitical abilities see every detail of it …
I think you're overestimating the complicity here, this is not an issue that involves much of analytical abilities.
Quote:
...and our leaders know all there is to know about it.
Quote:
This law is there because we all need it - they don't exactly hire basket weavers to make laws, do they.
Quote:
It's for our own good and we must be grateful to our gov't that we have such people who take care even of this side of our lives.
Ну прям "Спасибо товарищу Сталину за наше счастливое детство" или "Прошла зима, настало лето, спасибо Партии за это". :lol: Sorry, couldn't help, but it really brings up that kind of associations to my mind :)
Don't you think that with that kind of logic (btw, that would be an interesting exercise :) ) it's quite easy to justify a totalitarian state? (and I seriously doubt that you would like to live in one).