Thread: is б = бы ?

"Если бы б меня б не трогали б, я б молчал бы".
Откуда-то из Чехова.

Originally Posted by wanja

"Если бы б меня б не трогали б, я б молчал бы".
Откуда-то из Чехова.

Hey, is that a riddle or something?

Originally Posted by tohca

Hey, is that a riddle or something?

This is an illustration where in the sentence you can put "бы". Basically you can put it everywhere but putting too much of it is stylistically weird. Normally it should be one "бы" at each clause.

Originally Posted by wanja

"Если бы б меня б не трогали б, я б молчал бы".
Откуда-то из Чехова.

This could be translated in two ways:

"If they hadn't touched me, I would be quiet."

OR

"If only they hadn't touched me, I would be quiet!!!"

I'm not totally sure (without more context) about which is the better translation. For Russians, note that the difference between "if XYZ had happened" and "if only XYZ had happened" is that "only" transforms a "neutral" contrary-to-fact statement into a strongly emotional wish. In other words, the difference is not simply stylistic in English. But as far as I know, "если бы" can have both meanings.