Thread: Emphasis on a word, corresponding with English "does" or "did"

"She doesn't speak English but she speaks Russian." vs.
"She doesn't speak English but she does speak Russian."

Насколько я понял, в этих примерах с логической точки зрения ударение падает на "English" и на "Russian", а с грамматической - на "speak". Т.е. сама фраза получается абсурдной.
Союз "but" говорит о противопоставлении одного другому ("по-английски" противопоставляется "по-русски"), но акцент почему-то делается на действии "говорит".

Сepo, если Вы хотели противопоставить друг другу действия и сделать акцент на этом, то нужно было бы сказать что-то типа:
"She doesn't speak English but she does write English." = "Она не говорит по-английски, но зато пишет."

Если Вы хотели противопоставить друг другу языки ("по-английски" и "по-русски") и сделать акцент на этом, то нужно было бы сказать что-то типа:
"It is English that she doesn't speak but it is Russian that she speak." = "По-английски она не говорит, а вот по-русски умеет."


I'll try to say the same in English:
As far as I've understood, in your examples, the logical emphasis was made on "English" and "Russian" but the grammatically one on "speak". And then the phrase turns out "absurd". Don't be offended )
The conjunction "but" tells us one thing contrasts with another (i.e. "English" vs "Russian") but the emphasis you made on the act "speak".

Сepo, if you want to contrasts acts with each other and make the emphasis on that, you should say something like this:
"She doesn't speak English but she does write English." = "Она не говорит по-английски, но зато пишет."

If you want to contrasts the languages with each other ("English" and "Russian") and make the emphasis on that, you should say something like this:
"It is English that she doesn't speak but it is Russian that she speak." = "По-английски она не говорит, а вот по-русски умеет."

Oldboy, if I understand you right you think that something is wrong with cepo's sentences, but there isn't. They are absolutely valid English utterances, and the "does" adds emphasis to its verb phrase. "She does speak English" highlights the fact that she is able to speak English, probably as a second language, if not Russian, whereas the other sentence simply contrasts being able to speak the one language but not the other.

However, your post does answer (see, I'm doing it, too! "Does answer" adds emphasis.) the original question inadvertently. Your example ""По-английски она не говорит, а вот по-русски умеет." achieves what the added "does" achieves by adding the particle вот. Such particles are a way to add emphasis or slant the meaning of an utterance in a specific direction.

bitpicker, the sentences of cepo is valid from a grammatical point of view but not, IMHO, from a logical one.
I think so because in "She doesn't speak English but she does speak Russian."

Originally Posted by oldboy

the logical emphasis was made on "English" and "Russian" but the grammatically one on "speak".

I can only say "no" to that one. There is no difference between logical and grammatical emphasis here. "Do" is a handle which manipulates the verb phrase outside of simple affirmative sentences, and the verb phrase is "speak [language]".

Simple affirmative: she speaks [language].
Question: does she speak [language]?
Negative: She doesn't speak [language].
Emphatic affirmative: she does speak [language].

The difference you imply with your example "She doesn't speak English but she does write English.", which seems to state that somehow the emphasis is restricted to the verb itself and not the verb phrase, so that you'd expect the verb to change, does not exist in English. In fact, The stub sentence "she doesn't speak English, but she does" up to this point leaves it open whether the negated element is only the verb, as in your example, or is the whole verb phrase, as in cepo's example. Thats why you have to repeat both the verb and the language; you can neither say "but she does write." without at least adding "it", nor "but she does English." without repeating the verb (OK, that would probably be possible in colloquial speech, but not in writing).

And your alternative sentence "It is English that she doesn't speak but it is Russian that she speaks." even with the third person -s is extremely awkward and not a sentence you'd find commonly formed by any native speaker.

"She doesn't speak English but she speaks Russian." vs.
"She doesn't speak English but she does speak Russian."

There's no difference in connotation between these sentences in English. The "but" is contrastive, so the "does" makes no difference. The only reason you'd choose either variant was if Russian had some sort of contextual relevance. For example, let's say my boss asks me to meet a visitor at the airport. I ask "does she speak English?", and my boss, who knows that I speak Russian, answers "She doesn't speak English but she [speaks/ does speak] Russian." There's not the slightest difference there.

The simple affirmative version would be "She doesn't speak English. She speaks Russian."