Thread: UK spies unable to crack coded message from WWII carrier pigeon

Okay you smart people.... crack this code!!!!




Link to the full message


(CNN) -- Not even the British spy agencies that inspired James Bond can solve the mystery of a secret World War II message recently found on the skeleton of a carrier pigeon in a house chimney.

The meaning of the encoded message apparently died about 70 years ago with the wayward pigeon that David Martin found in his smokestack in Bletchingley, Surrey County, England.

Martin recently discovered the bird's remains with the surprisingly intact message inside a small red canister attached to a leg bone.

The only hope appears to be curators at the Pigeon Museum at Bletchley Park, who are now trying to trace the origins of two alphanumeric identifiers for the pigeon that were also written on the message, the UK intelligence agency GCHQ said this week.

"If they are identified and their wartime service established, it could help to decode the message," the agency said about the pigeon's identity numbers.
To the casual reader, the message is indecipherable.

Hand-written on a small piece of paper labeled "Pigeon Service," the note consists of five-letter words. Those words don't make sense: The jumble begins with "AOAKN" and "HVPKD." In all, the message consists of 27 five-letter code groups.

Deciphering the message requires codebooks and possibly a "one-time pad" encryption system, and those materials "will normally have been destroyed once no longer in use," the agency said. There is a small chance that a codebook survived.

"Without access to the relevant codebooks and details of any additional encryption used, it will remain impossible to decrypt," the agency said.
The one-time pad encryption gave the note added security. A random key is used to encrypt only one message.

"The advantage of this system is that, if used correctly, it is unbreakable as long as the key is kept secret," the agency said. "The disadvantage is that both the sending and receiving parties need to have access to the same key, which usually means producing and sharing a large keypad in advance."

Heightening the mystery are three other issues: The message is undated, the meaning of its destination of "X02" is unknown, and analysts can't identify the sender's signature or his unit.

"Unfortunately, much of the vital information that would indicate the context of the message is missing," the intelligence service said.

The sender's sign-off appears to say "Sjt W Stot," using an abbreviation for "serjeant," an old-fashioned spelling for "sergeant," the agency said.
The use of "Sjt" links the message to the army, the spy agency said.

"If 'Sjt Stot' and addressee X02 could be identified, it could give us a better idea of where to look for the information," the agency said.

About 250,000 pigeons were used during World War II by all branches of the military and the Special Operations Executive, the UK intelligence agency said.
Flying from mainland Europe to Britain, the birds heroically delivered all sorts of messages through a gauntlet of enemy hawk patrols and potshots from soldiers.

"Although it is disappointing that we cannot yet read the message brought back by a brave carrier pigeon, it is a tribute to the skills of the wartime code-makers that, despite working under severe pressure, they devised a code that was undecipherable both then and now," said GCHQ, one of three UK intelligence agencies.

I have deciphered it! It says "For God's sake, SEND US TOILET PAPER!!!!"

It is clearly explained why it can't be cracked. Properly produced code with one-time message-size key is unbreakable in principle without the key. Basically ANY combination of 135 or less symbols can be encrypted here. Give me any message and I'll give you the key, which produce your message from that code.

(Well, that was rhetoric, actually I will not. I am too lazy.)

Sorry for hijacking, but maybe some of you savvy tech guys smart enough to crack not only the letter above but also Voynich_manuscript just for fun!

Originally Posted by it-ogo

It is clearly explained why it can't be cracked. Properly produced code with one-time message-size key is unbreakable in principle without the key. Basically ANY combination of 135 or less symbols can be encrypted here. Give me any message and I'll give you the key, which produce your message from that code.

(Well, that was rhetoric, actually I will not. I am too lazy.)

it-ogo, ya know, I did read the article and yet you explained it much better than they did!!! You should be my geek speak translator! Once I read your post I went back and re-read the article and the light bulb went on and I understood and yet... part of me still thinks that in this day and age of computer hackers and all these geeks out there that one could not crack the code?